Our Story

We’re a national wholesale closeouts dealer headquartered in Millburn, New Jersey, just west of New York City. A family-owned company in its second generation, Gotham Sales lives by a guiding principle of my father, who founded the company in 1991. A child of the Great Depression, he believed that each of us comes into and leaves this world with nothing except our reputation.

Our business is repeat business
Standing by our word is why we have had such a loyal customer base since we opened our closeouts division in 2007. Our lots are exclusive to a single buyer, eliminating same-product competition from other vendors. Our customers, the vast majority we have had for the last decade, point to this as a prime reason for partnering with us.

Questions? Please ask.

Danny Schwartzstein

Gotham Sales

Choose a trusted partner. Go Gotham.

Gotham Sales also sells extended service plans for consumer appliances. Learn more here.

Contact Us


Gotham’s spotless record of customer satisfaction is reflected in its Better Business Bureau rating.


No. of truckloads of goods shipped to close-out buyers in the last three years


Percentage of repeat close-out customers