Our Story

Gotham Sales is a national wholesale distributor of extended service plans headquartered in Millburn, New Jersey, just west of New York City. A family-owned company in its second generation, Gotham lives by a guiding principle of my father, who founded the company in 1991. A child of the Great Depression, he believed that each of us comes into and leaves this world with nothing but our reputation.

Our business is repeat business. Standing by our word is why we have a loyal customer base, ranging from large national retailers to small businesses operating a single brick-and-mortar store. It also helps explain why more than 150 of our clients have been with us for more than a decade.

You won’t find another company like ours. Being fair to your retail customers is what drives us, even when that means going beyond service plan terms and conditions. For maximum satisfaction, we rely on our team’s dedication, our network of vetted experts, and over 10,000 licensed and insured manufacturer-authorized service centers available through New Leaf, our highly regarded, extended service plan partner.

Questions? Please ask.

Danny Schwartzstein

Gotham Sales

Choose a trusted partner. Go Gotham.

Gotham Sales also offers high-quality closeouts. Learn more here.

Meet Our Team


Danny Schwartzstein


Edward Guss

VP, Sales Extended Service Plans

Jeffrey Dahl

VP, Sales Closeout Division

Better Business Bureau ratings

  • A+
    Gotham’s spotless record of customer satisfaction is reflected in its Better Business Bureau rating.
  • A-
    Our partner, New Leaf, has an excellent BBB record based, in part, on its responsiveness to customer issues.



Licensed and insured manufacturer-authorized service centers nationwide used by our partner, New Leaf

Retailers trusting Gotham as their extended service plan administrator for over 10 years